Although some of the 30-plus banks that are getting money from the Treasury Department through its $700 billion financial-industry rescue program have cut dividends in response to tough financial conditions, only one has suspended them.
In fact, BailoutSleuth's analysis of the quarterly payouts by those banks shows that at least 10 will initially provide greater annual dividend yields to shareholders than they will to taxpayers supplying the new capital.
At current stock prices and dividend rates, the annual yield on the 10 banks' common shares will exceed the 5 percent that they are paying on the preferred shares they are selling to the federal government.
Politicians from both major political parties have complained about the possibility that banks getting taxpayer money will use the cash for shareholder dividends and employee bonuses, instead of making loans needed to ease tight credit and stimulate the economy.
Some bankers have countered that the money used for dividends and compensation comes from different pools of capital. And the White House has defended the dividend payments, suggesting that certain investors, including retirees, who bought bank stocks with the expectation of steady, attractive dividends would suffer further harm.
"I think some critics believe that only rich people get dividend payments,'' said Dana Perino, White House spokesperson, in a press briefing on Friday. "And that is not the case. Mutual funds, retirees, teachers, pension funds are all beneficiaries of dividend payments. They get dividend payments from banks."
Some of the bank that are getting the biggest chunks of government money also pay the biggest relative dividends.
Merrill Lynch Inc., which is in the process of being taken over by Bank of America Corp., pays a quarterly dividend of 35 cents a share on its common stock. That translates to $1.40 annually.
At its current stock price, its dividend yield would be in the neighborhood of 7.5 percent a year, according to calculations by Morningstar Inc.
Merrill Lynch is getting $10 billion through the sale of preferred stock to the Treasury Department. Under the terms of the investment deals with the government, banks pay dividends of 5 percent on those shares the first five years and 9 percent after that.
The deals also give the Treasury Department warrants to buy a certain amount of common stock in the banks at a later date, but there is no guarantee that those rights will have any value.
Bank of America got $15 billion through the Treasury Department program. It cut its quarterly dividend in half last month, and now pays the equivalent of $1.28 a share per year. Even with that adjustment, the annual dividend yield at its current share price is around 5.3 percent.
Morgan Stanley also is getting $10 million from the government. It pays $1.08 a share in dividends on its common stock. At its current stock price, the annual dividend yield would be around 6.2 percent.
US Bancorp said Monday it has been selected for the program and would sell $6.6 billion in preferred stock to the Treasury Department. The Minneapolis-based bank pays the equivalent of $1.70 a year in dividends on its common stock.
At its current share price, that translates to an annual dividend yield of 5.7 percent, according to Morningstar's data.
Marshall & Ilsley Corp., which has headquarters in Milwaukee, has signed up for $1.7 billion in government capital. It pays dividends on its common shares at a rate of $1.28 a year, which translates at the moment to an annual dividend yield of 7.1 percent.
Keycorp, of Cleveland, is getting $2.5 billion from the Treasury Department. It cut its dividend by 50 percent in June, to an annual rate of 75 cents a share. Even so, the annual dividend yield is around 6 percent.
Four other banks - BB&T Corp., Fifth Third Bancorp, Huntington Bancshares Inc. and First Financial Bancorp - all have current annual dividend yields ranging from 5.1 percent to 5.6 percent, according to Morningstar.
Together, those banks are getting nearly $8 billion. All of their dividend yields -- like those of the other banks mentioned above -- could decline if their share prices rise or their dividend payouts fall.
Midwest Banc Holdings Inc. was another new addition to the bailout list on Monday. The bank, based in Melrose Park, Ill., announced that it had been approved to sell $85.5 million in preferred stock to the Treasury Department.
Midwest Banc Holdings suspended its third quarter dividend last month. It reported a loss of $159.7 million for the third quarter, reflecting loan losses and the write-off of its $67 million in preferred stock it held in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, two government-sponsored entities that buy mortgages.